dental water additive for dogs

DIY vs. Store-Bought: Making an Informed Choice on Dog Water Additives

Choosing the right water additives for your pup can be tricky. So many options! It's important to pick something that suits your dog's needs and your preferences. We'll explore homemade vs. store-bought additives, with recipes & tips.

Homemade has a few advantages - you control the ingredients & it can be more cost-effective. But store-bought is convenient, with a wider variety & scientific research to back it up.

If you go DIY, here are a few recipes & tips:

  • For fresh breath: parsley extract or chlorophyll.
  • For joint health: glucosamine/fish oil.
  • Thirsty in summer? Freeze low-sodium chicken broth into ice cubes & add to the bowl.

My friend had a picky eater. She tried making flavored water using natural fruit extracts. Her pup loved it & started drinking more than ever!

Pros and Cons of Homemade Water Additives

When deciding on dog water additives, it's vital to think about homemade options' pros and cons. Homemade additives provide control of ingredients, but store-bought products offer convenience and experts in formulation.

Let's look at homemade water additives' pros and cons:


  • Control over ingredients – customize the additive for specific needs.
  • Natural or organic ingredients for healthier option.
  • Experiment with different flavors for your pet.


  • Time and effort for sourcing, preparation, and storage.
  • Quality control challenges without professional guidance.
  • Cost-effective, but lacking professional expertise.

It's important to talk to your veterinarian before adding any new additives to your dog's diet. They can help determine if a homemade or store-bought option is best.

Homemade water additives originated when pet owners aimed to personalize their furry friends' hydration routine.

To sum up, while homemade additives provide flexibility and cost savings, commercial products tend to be scientifically precise. Weigh the pros and cons before making an informed choice that fits your pup's needs. Remember, your dog's health should always come first.

Pros and Cons of Commercial Water Additives

Commercial water additives for dogs come with advantages and disadvantages. Let's take a look at these pros and cons in detail.

Pros Cons
Convenient to use Artificial ingredients
Dental benefits Dogs may not like taste
Freshens breath Expensive compared to DIY
Prevents tartar build-up Unnecessary additives

Using water additives is convenient and provides dental benefits like freshening breath and preventing tartar build-up. However, some dogs may not like the taste. Plus, these products can be pricey compared to homemade alternatives and may contain artificial ingredients or unnecessary additives.

It is important to read labels carefully when buying commercial water additives. This will help you know if there are potential allergens or ingredients that are not suitable for your pet's specific dietary requirements or sensitivities.

There are different types of commercial water additives. Some focus on dental health while others prioritize breath freshening. Choose a product based on your pet's individual needs and preferences.

An example of the importance of being cautious when selecting a commercial water additive is that of my friend. She purchased a well-known brand without reading the ingredients list. Her dog had an adverse reaction due to an undetected allergy. This shows why it's important to research products before using them on our furry friends.

Recipes for Homemade Water Additives

Creating your own water additives for your dog can be a fantastic way to guarantee their health and happiness. You only need some basic ingredients to make personalized mixes that offer multiple benefits. Here's some recipes and advice for anyone wanting to give the DIY option a go!

Recipes for Homemade Water Additives:

Recipe Ingredients Instructions
Apple Cider Vinegar 1 cup apple cider vinegar Mix apple cider vinegar with water in a 1:10 ratio
Vinegar 9 cups water Stir well and add to your dog's water bowl

Apple Cider Vinegar: This water additive is known for aiding digestion, strengthening the immune system and fighting urinary tract infections. It's easy to make by combining 1 cup of ACV with 9 cups of water. Give it a stir and add it to your pup's water bowl.

Something special to note is that apple cider vinegar also works as a flea and tick repellent if you apply it as a spray to their fur. This natural ingredient has been used for centuries due to its healing traits.

It's been around since ancient times as an all-purpose cure for humans and animals, and its popularity has continued until today because of its efficiency and ease of use.

By choosing thoughtfully when it comes to dog water additives, you can make sure your pet receives the best care possible. Whether you go for homemade or store-bought options, always consider your furry friend's needs and check with a vet if necessary. Your pup's health is worth the extra effort!

Tips for Those Who Want to Try the DIY Route

  1. Research is essential. Get the facts on ingredients, their advantages and any possible risks.
  2. Be careful when mixing. Too much of an ingredient can be harmful.
  3. Quality counts. Use organic options where possible.
  4. Experiment with different recipes and combos for tailored care.
  5. Take action! Have fun and provide the best for your pet.


When you pick between homemade and store-bought water additives for your pup, there are pros and cons to consider. Making your own blend gives you control over the ingredients. You can tailor the mix to your pup's needs. Plus, it could save you money. But, it takes effort and knowledge to get the proportions right. And, it lacks the testing of store-bought products.

On the other hand, store-bought water additives offer convenience. They've been carefully researched and tested. Plus, they come in various flavors that appeal to picky eaters. But they may contain artificial preservatives and be more expensive in the long run.

My friend once tried making her own water additive for her elderly dog with dental issues. She blended parsley flakes, cinnamon powder, and coconut oil with water. Her pup's breath and dental health improved drastically. DIY water additives can be great for specific canine needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

FAQ 1: Is it better to use homemade water additives or commercial products for my dog?

There is no definitive answer to this question as it depends on various factors. Homemade water additives offer the benefit of being natural and customizable, allowing you to control the ingredients and avoid chemicals. On the other hand, commercial products are formulated by experts and often undergo rigorous testing to ensure safety and effectiveness.

FAQ 2: Are homemade water additives for dogs safe?

When prepared and used correctly, homemade water additives can be safe for your dog. However, it is important to research and use ingredients that are known to be safe for dogs. Consulting with a veterinarian is also recommended for guidance and to address any specific health concerns your dog may have.

FAQ 3: What are the potential benefits of homemade water additives?

Homemade water additives allow you to customize the flavors and nutrients based on your dog's preferences and needs. They can help enhance the taste of water, encourage hydration, and provide additional health benefits such as improved digestion or joint support, depending on the chosen ingredients.

FAQ 4: What are the advantages of using commercial water additives?

Commercial water additives often have a wide range of formulations tailored to address specific issues such as dental health, bad breath, or urinary tract support. They are convenient and ready to use, saving you time and effort compared to making them at home. Additionally, reputable brands ensure consistent quality and safety.

FAQ 5: Can you provide a DIY recipe for a homemade water additive?

Certainly! Here's a simple DIY recipe: Mix together 1 cup of filtered water, 1 teaspoon of plain yogurt, and 1 tablespoon of chopped fresh mint leaves. Allow the mixture to infuse overnight in the refrigerator, then strain and add a tablespoon to your dog's water bowl. Remember to consult a veterinarian for any specific dietary restrictions or modifications.

FAQ 6: How do I decide whether to try DIY or store-bought water additives?

The choice between DIY and store-bought water additives depends on your preferences, available time, and your dog's specific needs. If you enjoy experimenting with flavors and have the time to prepare homemade additives, DIY might be a good fit. On the other hand, if convenience, specialized formulations, and expert-backed products are important to you, store-bought options might be the way to go. We recommend considering your lifestyle and consulting with a veterinarian for personalized advice.

Back to blog

Top Products

Your Furry Friend Deserves the Best

Our veterinary recommended selection of top pet health products promises to nurture your pets well-being. From advanced nutritional supplements to innovative grooming solutions, explore the essentials that ensure a happier, healthier life for your beloved companions. Discover our range of premium choices, all designed with your pet's health and happiness in mind.

1 of 4